They were children. Jamie had Beth sterilized because he felt that she were not in a position to make the right decision for herself in the matter due to her mental disability. Yellowstone season 4 release date: Will there be another series? So, he loads his scared younger sister into his car and takes her to a nearby abortion clinic. ET on Paramount Network. Yellowstone: Who plays Chief Rainwater in Yellowstone? A hysterectomy is a procedure used to sterilize women where the uterus is removed through the women's abdomen or vagina. What are the signs of a one-sided marriage? Jamie just learned that he was adopted when he was a baby after years of experiencing a strange distance between himself and his family. Their toxic relationship is also caused by their differing views on values and morals. Although laws regarding abortion can vary wildly from state to state, this fan asserted the clinic shouldnt have been able to perform sterilisation surgery since procedures were banned before the events of the series. New York, While Kevin Costner and company were out making a motorcycle gang dig their own graves, it's the women of Yellowstone who are doing the heavy lifting. Jamie sought answers from his father after he discovered John was not his biological dad. There is a high chance he will abandon the family for good, especially after he discovered who his real father is. Actress Kelly Reilly portrays the character, while Kylie Rogers stars as younger Beth in flashback episodes. We are one of the worlds fastest growing The story goes that John and Evelyn adopted a three-month-old Jamie after his biological father murdered his biological mother. What is it? This momentous life event caused Beth to grow up resenting Jamie - who didn't tell her in the process of her abortion that she was also being sterilized. Of course, it's going to crush you and make you hate somebody.". I love your brother. Either Beth has an incredible sixth sense and realized it, or she learned that Jamie is adopted and kept the truth from him. More info. This was until the episode on Sunday, July 26th. Beth Dutton is a feisty financier and daughter of leading light John Dutton (Kevin Costner). Many said that its incredible that the show took a few seasons to finally address the feud between the two siblings. That is another biggie. The Boys season 2 release date, cast, trailer, plot: When is it out? She is wearing the same golden dress on both occasions, in case you were curious. Well, Jamie says that he has no other option given that their last name is Dutton, and the family is very highly known due to the massive Yellowstone ranch and that John is the Livestock Commissioner. Is that a real thing?. He had no idea what he was doing. That, she tells him, is what truly makes him evil and nothing else. Why did Jamie sterilize Beth? I was wondering why she hated her brother so much!, Another one reacted: I didnt ask you for a hysterectomy. That one line from @Yellowstone Beth Dutton summed up sibling hatred in a single sentence., It all now makes sense why Beth hates Jamie's guts; how U don't tell your sister about the hysterectomy she's gonna get along w/ her abortion?? You know whats so dangerous about you, Jamie? Additionally, Beth never told Rip that he got her pregnant or about the abortion and sterilization. All these years, the Dutton family never addressed the elephant in the room, but in Season 3, they are all going gung-ho. Jamie rebuffs her by telling her that it was Beth who came to him seeking help. Yellowstone season 4: Beth Dutton death 'sealed' after Rip's warning? Jamie agreed to proceed with the abortion without telling Beth of the consequences . Beth loathes Jamie. Beth's drug abuse caused damage to her reproductive system, specifically her ovaries, which resulted in infertility. Express has gathered together various fan comments from IMDb, and one individual. reporters on a platform technologically tailored to meet the needs of the modern reader. Over on Reddit, some viewers have raised the contentious plot point as a major factor for season threes perceived dip in quality. She said: "It's fun I get to be that woman they despise.". In an impossibly difficult moment, she clarifies and says, "When you consider the pain you cause a person the person's fault? This explains why he is ignorant about his sisters anger. Also, do you think if people found out, it would have significantly hurt the family from a political perspective? Jamie begged Beth not to expose his secret and decided the best option was to kill Garrett and in emotionally-charged scenes, the two told each other they loved one another before Jamie whisked . What was his motivation for the hysterectomy. When Beth found out the truth, she developed a hatred for Jamie and blamed him for her infertility. He believes that Beth is at fault for blaming him all these years, as it was not him who had placed her in that situation. Secondly, Beth's father John was exposed to radiation during his time as a miner, and this exposure could have been passed on to Beth through her genes. Whenever Beth saw her nephew Tate (Brecken Merrill) she felt a pang of grief as she knew she would never experience loving a child, because of Jamie. DON'T MISS:Haunting of Bly Manor spoilers: Dani star reveals if shes really dead[INSIGHT]Money Heist season 5 theories: Alicia Sierras fate confirmed[THEORY]The Masked Singer: Controversial TV star sent home in first appearance[REACTION]. While the timeline may not precisely add up with what really happened, it certainly explains the tumultuous relationship between Beth and Jamie, and hopefully, it encourages people to look into the real, horrific story of how Native Americans have been treated in the United States. After all, prior to just recently Beth treated Rip like he was just a cheap F*ck that she didn't even like. John Dutton was mad. Express. Beth has always had a strong relationship with her father, so she was unable to understand why Jamie wanted to make life difficult for him. Why did Jamie have Beth sterilized? One commented: Am I wrong, but wasnt it far fetched that reservation abortions comes with a free sterilization? This operation was routinely used to sterilize Native American women during the 1960s and 1970s in the United States. Buckle up, buckle bunnies. They explained: It's revealed that Beth resents her brother Jamie because when she discovered she was pregnant, at about age 16, Jamie took her to a Reservation (Native American) health clinic for an abortion. Why did Jamie have Beth sterilized? Jamie took the decision for Beth, without consulting with her, and didnt reveal the consequences of the medical procedure. Yellowstone: Fans realised why Rip and Beth can't have kids, Yellowstone: Jamie forced his sister to get sterilised, Haunting of Bly Manor spoilers: Dani star reveals if shes really dead, Money Heist season 5 theories: Alicia Sierras fate confirmed, The Masked Singer: Controversial TV star sent home in first appearance, Yellowstone season 4 theories: Fans seal Roarke and Rainwater team up, Yellowstone: Denim Richards reveals best thing about playing Colby. The Season 3 finale is rapidly approaching, which means time is of the essence to see if any of these inquiries are resolved. Jamie doesnt know what to do either since he was only a young and dumb teenager at the time. Randall was quick to confess and justify his crimes when he met him. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. "Yepit's always the suits that are more dangerous and evil than the obvious ones.". And another user elaborated: The story seems directionless with main female characters wearing less clothes, wanting sex, and kind of useless in this season. Although he was caught in a difficult position, it seems like a drastic measure to take. Viewers at home have often noticed clashes between Beth and Jamie, but never fully understood what happened between the two siblings. Cookies help us deliver our Services. The Dutton family were torn apart yet again in the closing moments of Yellowstones third season finale this year. His perspective was that he was there to Beth in her time of need and tried his best for everyone. What happened to her? But he had a change of heart at the eleventh hour and withdrew from the election. Jamie had zero motive other than not letting Dad find out." As her elder brother, all he did was protect her and the family's reputation. READ MORE:Yellowstone fans gobsmacked as former star returns to surprise Jamie. He took her right to have children a way from her John Dutton was mad , I mean Jaime trash for not telling her about the hysterectomy part but Beth wanted the situation handled and it was handledtheyre both guilty #YellowstoneTV, How to watch Wynonna Earp season 4: UK fans left waiting as new episodes arrive stateside. Now, Beth cannot carry Rips children when they get married well, if they get married. By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. We later learned that the ex-prisoner was responsible for the attacks on the Dutton family towards the end of Season 3. The nurses had told Jamie how they could only sterilize Beth and she would no longer be able to have children. Beth would never forgive Jamie for leaving her in the dark about the implications of the abortion. Fans are still reeling from that devastatingYellowstoneseason 3 finale. Throughout the previous two seasons fans were in the dark about why there was so much animosity between the pair, however a recent episode revealed in a telling flashback what happened between the two of them to create such a fraught dynamic. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. One fan said: "It all now makes sense why Beth hates Jamie's guts. Reilly spoke to KTLA 5 about season three, she said some fans believed she had the potential to hurt those close to her. When they were teenagers, Rip got Beth pregnant, and she went to Jamie for help. It just wasnt well thought out, and from his standpoint, he wasnt sure. . Home of the Daily and Sunday Express. Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, Cinemablend is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. The life-altering decision Jamie made for Beth is utterly devastating. Cole Hauser: What else has Yellowstone's Cole Hauser starred in? What John Goodman And The Conners Showrunner Have Said About The ABC Series Ending, 90 Day Fianc's Biniyam Shibre Is Going From MMA To Marvel, Because Of Course He Is, Bruce Willis Wife Emma Sends Love To The Die Hard Actor And His Pink Suit In Sweet Throwback Post. She slowly deconstructs Jamie and tells him exactly what is wrong with him, his perspective of the world, and his distinction between right and wrong. John is in disbelief to know that Jamie would do something like this and a graver reality dawns upon him -- he has lost another grandchild. Beth and Jamie fights never disappoint. Why did Jamie have Beth Sterilized? Has Beth known the truth for a while now? Theres a lot packed into that little scene for Jamie and Beth. Beth had a hysterectomy when her brother Jamie took her to a hospital to have an abortion. Hanna season 3 release date, cast, trailer, plot: When is Hanna out. Beth, who is aware of Jamie's family history, believes Jamie has evil qualities and has made it her mission to make Jamie's life miserable. Will Rip ever find out that was Jamies doing? Jamie and Beth's secret could have an impact on the family dynamic after John found out the truth. When they were teenagers, Rip got Beth pregnant, and she went to Jamie for help. The nurses had told Jamie how they could only sterilize Beth and she would no longer be able to have children. You justify every act before you commit them, Beth tells Jamie in one scene. Beth has been diagnosed with an intellectual disability and was deemed to have a limited capacity to understand the process of pregnancy and parenting. 3. Kevin Costner first wife: Who was star previously married to? And Taylor Sheridan's popular sweeping western has changed its tune in its third season. Will Rip ever learn the truth? Jamie should have known that Beth would eventually learn she cannot have children. Yepit's always the suits that are more dangerous & evil than the obvious ones smh #BloodAintAlwaysThicker #YellowstoneTV pic.twitter.com/e4UdJ1GU7m, @YellowstoneFans I'm soso glad Beth told her Dad what Jamie did to her the hysterectomy.